Cotuit Kettleers Award Winners (1962-Present)
| Crawford MVP Award | Bernie Kilroy MVP Pitcher Award | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year | Player | College | Player | College |
| 2018 | Michael Toglia | UCLA | Stephen Schoch | U. Maryland Balt. Cty |
| 2017 | Griffin Conine | Duke | Zane Collins | Wright St. |
| 2016 | Quinn Brodey | Stanford | Eddie Muhl | George Washington |
| 2015 | Michael Paez | Coastal Carolina | Jonathan Woodcock | Virginia Tech |
| 2014 | Logan Taylor | Texas A&M | Adam Whitt | Univ. Nevada |
| 2013 | Rhett Wiseman | Vanderbilt | Jared Walsh | Georgia |
| 2012 | Patrick Biondi | Michigan | Ryan Connolly | Coastal Carolina |
| 2011 | Victor Roache | Georgia Southern | Chris Beck | Georgia Southern |
| 2010 | Jordan Leyland | UC Irvine | Austin Wood | St. Petersburg CC |
| 2009 | Zack Cox | Arkansas | Jake Buchanan | North Carolina State |
| 2008 | Kevin Patterson | Auburn | Seth Blair | Arizona State Univ. |
| 2007 | Reese Havens | Univ. S. Carolina | Josh Lindblom | Purdue |
| 2006 | Justin Smoak | Univ. S. Carolina | James Simmons | UC Riverside |
| Eric Farris | Loyola Marymount | (First Year Awarded 2006) | ||
| 2005 | Sean Gaston | Notre Dame | ||
| 2004 | Chase Headley | Univ of Tennesee | ||
| 2003 | Eric Nielsen | UNLV | ||
| 2002 | Pete Stonard | Alabama | ||
| 2001 | Brent Metheny | James Madison | ||
| 2000 | Nick Glazer | Clemson | ||
| 1999 | Garrett Atkins | UCLA | ||
| Rich Thompson | James Madison | |||
| 1998 | Jeff Heaverlo | Washington | ||
| 1997 | John Scheschuk | Texas A&M | ||
| 1996 | Jack Cressend | Tulane | ||
| 1995 | Josh Paul | Vanderbilt | ||
| 1994 | Joe Funaro | E. Connecticut | ||
| 1993 | Ray Ricken | Michigan | ||
| 1992 | John Kelly | Connecticut | ||
| 1991 | Chris Widger | George Mason | ||
| 1990 | Ray Suplee | Georgia | ||
| 1989 | J. R. "Buck" Showalter | Georgia | ||
| 1988 | David Krol | Toledo | ||
| 1987 | Billy Masse | Davidson | ||
| 1986 | Cris Carpenter | Georgia | ||
| 1985 | Greg Vaughn | Sacramento City | ||
| 1984 | Stu Weidie | New Orleans | ||
| 1983 | Greg Lotzar | Central Michigan | ||
| 1982 | Terry Steinbach | Minnesota | ||
| 1981 | Billy Dees | Arkansas | ||
| 1980 | Ron Darling | Yale | ||
| 1979 | Tim Tuefel | Clemson | ||
| 1978 | Randy LaVigne | Univ. of Connecticut | ||
| 1977 | Del Bender | Mississippi State | ||
| 1976 | Al Weston | Michigan State | ||
| 1975 | Paul OÕNeill | Boston College | ||
| 1974 | Jim Thomas | Texas Wesleyan | ||
| 1973 | Gene Quirk | Union | ||
| Danny Goodwin | Southern | |||
| 1972 | Joe Zylka | Rice | ||
| 1971 | Don Douglas | Amherst | ||
| 1970 | Natale Calamis | St. John's | ||
| 1969 | Nick Furlong | Notre Dame | ||
| 1968 | Peter Krull | Ohio State | ||
| 1967 | Tom Kelly | Holy Cross | ||
| 1966 | Tom Kelly | Holy Cross | ||
| 1965 | Bob Butkus | Bowdoin | ||
| 1964 | Ken Huebner | Florida Southern | ||
| 1963 | Jack McCarthy | Holy Cross | ||
| 1962 | Tony Capo | Holy Cross |